The Rock
from Rock & Ice, No. 125 June 1, 2003
In Cuba, the crags give hope and a glimpse of freedom
to a growing band of climbers isolated behind a wall of oppression
By Armando Menocal
Nice place to visit ... The lush Viñales
valley in mountainous western Cuba. Only 90 miles from Florida
and home to the best limestone this side of Thailand, the island
nation has recently seen an influx of climbers from all over
the world, raising eyebrows among Cuban officials. Viñales'
leading native climber Josué Millo yanking on Malanga
Hasta la Muerta. (5.12d/.13a). David Munilla.
"Your father spent three years in jail as a dissident, your
mother is a Jehovah's Witness and your brother is a homosexual,"
I said to the Cuban climber Josué Millo, as if this was
breaking news to him. "In Cuba, you are a man without hope.
Your neighbors spy on you and your government harasses you. None
of your family will ever get a good job."
"I know, man, I know," Josué said, but with
a chuckle of resigned acceptance. The two of us had pulled up
to a curb across from the local police station, in the town of
Viñales in western Cuba, patiently waiting for other climbers
to join us and share a cab for the four kilometers to El Palenque.
A bar by day and Vegas-style cabaret by night, El Palenque is
a natural grotto of limestone stalactites, pockets and knobs,
and is the most indulgent crag this side of Thailand. Bouldering
on the dozen or so problems is nothing if not novel: Squeeze a
few stalactites, then belly up to the bar for super-chilled beer
or frosty mojitos. In the evenings, scantily clad mulatto
dancers swing their buttocks and breasts as patrons puff intoxicatingly
on robust Cohibas.
Josué and other local Cuban climbers had been told by
the local policia not to climb with foreigners - the state's
latest effort to protect its communist ideals. Yet here he was
- the only one the government could not scare - cragging with
me, an American. It is no surprise that Josué is Viñales'
strongest climber (pulling down 5.12c after just two years) and
leader of the small but growing band of alpinistas.
Yesterday, the manager of El Palenque told Josué not to
come around with foreign climbers.
"He said that they might place a bomb," said Josué
. "Imagine that- a bomb on a climb!"
While Josué and I chatted he took great care to keep
the door of the taxi open, hiding us from view of the police.
Even Josué, for all of his bravado, knew not to push his
luck too far.
Valley of Hope
The Lonely Planet guidebook on Cuba calls Viñales a "miniature
Yosemite, with the most spectacular scenery in all of Cuba."
As a longtime Yosemite climber, I doubted that, but in 1999 could
no longer resist going there.
I returned to Cuba after a 40-year absence to find my family
roots, see firsthand the relic to a failed revolution and to check
out Viñales. My mother was born and raised in Cuba, and
my great-grandfather was a cousin of Mario Garcia Menocal , president
from 1912 to 1921, who fought to liberate Cuba from Spanish rule.
Cuba's most famous classical painter, Armando Menocal, shares
my given name.

Wild moves on American Rodeo (5.12b). Although
typically overhung, most Cuban limestone is covered with large
features. David Munilla.
In Viñales I found a large, open valley ringed by mountains
cut with dramatic, overhanging limestone faces. One-thousand-foot
freestanding crags called mogotes tower above verdant forest
of pines and palms, thatch-roofed houses and red-soiled farms.
While much of mountainous western Cuba boasts limestone cragging,
Viñales, with routes up to 500 feet high, is pre-eminent,
home to the majority of the island's 140-odd routes. In fact,
the area hosts "one of the coolest walls I've seen in North
America - a five-pitch wall topped by a 40-foot roof so featured
with buckets and stalactites that it goes at 5.12b," says
Colorado climber Craig Luebben. Luebben accompanied me on my second
trip to Cuba in 1999, and has since pioneered so many routes the
locals call him "Mr. Mogote." One of his new routes,
Cuba Libre (5.12), is an incredible line with a
wild, stalactite-dripping and pocketed 20-foot roof on the third
pitch.
Since our initial climbs in Viñales, the valley has become
a national park and eco-tourism has taken hold. Official "guides"
and "rangers" now accompany tourists on hikes through
the tobacco farms and around the mogotes. Watching rock climbers
is included on the officially authorized hiking circuit. For climbers,
the area remains virtually untapped. Uphill from El Palenque,
for example, you find a 1,300-foot cave band bristling with stalactites.
The valley alone, says Luebben, "has several lifetimes of
killer routes to be climbed."
Havana's famous Sea Side Street. Greg Von Doersten.
Right: Rest days in Cuba offer a host of unusual spectacles.Armando
Menocal.
|
Although the government desires tourists
it deeply fears interaction between foreigners and Cubans,
believing tourists could undermine its authority.
|
Behind the Iron Curtain
Despite living among stunning and fertile lands roughly the size
of Pennsylvania, most of the 11 million Cuban people are subjected
to extreme poverty under a Soviet-style communist government.
Cuba has struggled on despite losing economic and material support
when the Soviet Union collapsed over a decade ago, and despite
a nearly 40-year old U.S. trade embargo that makes even visiting
the island problematic.
Fidel Castro, the island's obstinate 76-year-old president,
calls Cuba a "Phoenix rising from the ashes," yet the
average annual income is $1,700 and the monthly allotment of staples
such as rice, sugar and cooking oil given to each citizen barely
makes it to the middle of the month. Most rural Cubans live in
thatched-roof "bohios" with dirt floors. They
cook over woodstoves and spend evenings by candlelight. Electricity
may run nearby, but only citizens in good standing with their
local "Committee to Defend the Revolution" may tap it.
Despite such hardships, most villagers are warm and friendly to
Americans - once they even sent hot lunches to us out at the crags.

You say you want a revolution? Typical Cuban
bohio, home to most rural workers.Armando Menocal.
Cuba is a paradox. As a socialist country, Cuba claims a classless
society, yet it is really divided into two classes: people with
dollars, and people with lower-valued pesos. Oddly, the government
of Cuba practices apartheid, excluding Cubans from its own resorts
and hotels, which it saves for foreign tourists. Almost everyone
can read, but Cubans are denied freedom of speech and press. According
to Human Rights Watch, reporters are routinely arrested for straying
from the party line - one outspoken journalist was conveniently
imprisoned for six months for "hoarding toys" that had
been paid for by exiled Cubans in Miami, and which he had planned
to give to poor children in his area. Other reporters have been
imprisoned for up to six years for insulting Castro.
Free education is available to all in Cuba, but doctors, teachers
and engineers might earn just $20 a month, and moonlight as waiters
or peddle rickshaws to make ends meet. Any free enterprise, however,
such as renting a room, serving a meal - even selling lemonade
at a stand -. is prohibited unless explicitly sanctioned, taxed
and regulated by the government. Impoverished families even get
hassled for letting foreigners stay at their homes for free.
After the evaporation of the massive Soviet subsidy in 1990,
the Cuban government turned to tourism to sustain its huge social
welfare bureaucracy. Although the government desires tourists
dollars, it deeply fears interaction between foreigners and Cubans,
believing tourists could undermine its authority.
Despite what the Viñales police told the Cuban climbers,
no law prevents a foreigner and Cuban from climbing together.
Instead, local officials, eager to wield their power, simply decided
that Cuban climbers should stay to themselves. Nonetheless, when
I'm in Cuba I climb mostly with Cubans, and many of the country's
major routes have been done by joint Cuban-foreign teams. Unfortunately,
it is always the Cubans, and not visitors, who pay the price for
breaking rules, written or unwritten.
Once for example, we took an unofficial taxi, a vintage 1958
Chevy that belonged to the driver, Joaquin, who was only licensed
to carry Cubans, not tourists. Joaquin, with eight of us in his
taxi, was nabbed at a roadblock outside of Viñales. His
car was confiscated. Despite our protests, all we could do was
name the new route we did that day Confiscado. Months later
I learned that Joaquin got his car back, after paying a hefty
fine in dollars, the equivalent of several years of work as a
taxi driver.

The American Cameron Cross on Mr. Mogote (5.12a).
At five pitches long, it's one of the Viñales valley's
lengthier undertakings. Note the tufa formations left and below
the climber.Craig Luebben.
The Long Climb to Freedom
"The Revolution was the work of climbers and cavers:"
Castro made that remark shortly after winning a bloody war and
wresting control of the government in 1959. Castro may have been
talking about the fact that the revolutionaries used the caves
and mountains of Cuba as their bases and hiding spots. Then again,
he may really have thought himself a climber. While he was fighting
the revolution in Cuba's Sierra Maestra mountains, Castro unsuccessfully
attempted to climb Pico Turquino, Cuba's highest peak, at 6,561
feet.
Because of Cuba's isolation as a Soviet satellite and the country's
relatively low standard of living, rock climbing has only slowly
taken root.In the early 1990s a small group of cavern in Havana,
eager to apply their spelunking skills to the numerous limestone
crags, taught themselves to climb using donated gear and articles
in an occasional climbing magazine.
The Cubans' initial approach to climbing fit their equipment
and experience, which at that point was limited to exploring the
island's many caves: drop in from above, drill an anchor and toprope
the route. Bolt hangers were removed for reuse.
|
Gato is so passionate about climbing
that when he successfully led a 5.lld for the first time
he cried as he was being lowered.
|
On my second trip to Cuba, accompanied by Luebben, we climbed
and explored the length of the island with two of the Havana-based
climbers, Vitalio Echazábal and Carlos Pinelo. Our group discovered
climbing possibilities in a few areas in central and eastern Cuba,
but none with the staggering potential of Viñales on the
western end of the island.
On our last day in Viñales, we were joined by another
eager Cuban, Aníbal Fernández, also from Havana. I did not know
it at the time, but this kid with cropped blond hair was AWOL
from the Cuban army and hitchhiked to Viñales to climb
with the visiting Americans. After we dropped him back off in
Havana, he went straight to the brig for two weeks.
Aníbal was one of the original core of the Havana climbers
that also included Vitalio, Jorge Mederos, Carlos, and Ananay
Jimenez. Vitalio, the most talented natural climber, was also
the gear wonk, making homemade nuts and hooks, and stitching packs
on a foot-pedal sewing machine. Mederos had just obtained his
degree as an entomologist, and wanted to study insect ecology
in Cuba's jungle canopies. He would have to do it without access
to libraries or research available on the web; even after I got
him a computer, he was not permitted access to the web. Mederos
was also the non-stop jester. A short man, he looked even more
farcical next to his taller and much bigger mulatto wife.
Most Cubans willing to comment on the regime or Castro do so
only jokingly. When the electricity goes out - a common occurrence
-Mederos goes out on his balcony and sings the Cuban national
anthem. A neighbor then steps outside, and yells, "Viva Fidel."
Of the Cubans who were the first generation of committed climbers,
only Aníbal remains in Cuba today. Climbing has been the vehicle
for the others to escape.
Carlos and Aníbal came to the U.S. in 2001 for a rock-guide
course created far them by Exum Mountain Guides. Aníbal took full
advantage, climbing walls ranging from the Rockies to Canyonlands
to Yosemite, including ascents of Zodiac on El Cap and
the Regular Northwest Face route on Half
Dome. But after two months he returned to Cuba: "I missed
Cuba so much," he says, "There are so many routes to
put up."
But, says Aníbal, "My climbing partners, Vitalio and Mederos,
are not there anymore."
Carlos dropped out of the guide course and stayed in San Francisco
where he was granted asylum. When asked how he feels about not
return ing to Cuba, Pinelo tells the story of another defected
Cuban who "goes into a room, takes out the light bulbs, closes
the windows and puts on a tape of one of Fidel's speeches"
to combat homesickness.
Vitalio, who was once caught trying to escape Cuba by sea, now
resides in Spain, where he hopes to gain residency. "I miss
Cuba very much," he says. "And the wonderful times climbing
there, and I know that it may be a long time before we can share
them again:"
Cuba is like a heart torn in two. People leave their homes and
go into exile abroad, but their dwellings stay behind to be inhabited
by another generation, many of whom also leave in second and third
generations of defections.
Although Cuba's total climbing population is just some two dozen
climbers, including its star, Josué, the number is slowly
growing and enthusiastic. In the spring of 2001, Aníbal arrived
in Viñales with his latest convert Dark and thin, Jorge
is aptly called Gato - "Cat." At 17, he was just spending
his days sitting on the stoop in front of his Havana house. He
started climbing with Aníbal and developed a daily bouldering
habit. Gato is so passionate about climbing that when he successfully
led a 5.lld for the first time he cried as he was being lowered.

The U.K.'s Neil Gresham, part of a strong international
team that visited Cuba last winter, powering out The Colony
(5.13c) in the Viñales valley. Mike Robertson.
Hope for the Future
After spending the majority of four winters there, I am a fixture
in Viñales, yet local officials still ask for my permit
to climb, or ask who gave me permission to climb, although no
law says that foreigners need permission. Recently, two officials
in Havana told a Cuban climber and me that all climbing in Viñales
had been prohibited. Then, a little later in the same interview,
the officials told us they were bringing 800 foreigners to climb
to Viñales. Two weeks later, the Cuban and I were climbing
together in Viñales, along with a dozen foreigners and
a large contingent of Havana climbers. The closure and 800 climbing
visitors never materialized.
In 2001 a security agent came to Viñales snooping on
me. He asked everyone I might have come in contact with what I
did, who I met, what I read, what I said about the Cuban government.
The investigation left me in a panic: Why would I be the target
of investigation? What could happen to me?
My Cuban friends, however, placed no importance on it. Being
investigated by the state is all the Cubans know and is as unremarkable
as water is to fish.
One Viñales local told me that the police tried to recruit
him to spy on climbers, but he said no. In fact, the Cuban climbers
already thought that this guy was a spy, and doubted his denial,
telling me that the police-recruitment story was fabricated to
mislead us.
A few days later, we were returning to Havana from Viñales.
Five of us were riding with our regular Viñales chauffeur,
Lugo, in his official mini-van taxi. With me were four Cubans:
Laura, Aníbal, Abel and Gato. The five of us exceeded the limit
of riders for the cab by one, and we stuffed Gato in the cubby
hole between the ceiling and the massive stack of our packs, covered
him with a foam pad and jokingly told him that he shouldn't move
if we were stopped - an unlikely event in an official taxi.

Tobacco is Cuba's second largest cash crop after
sugar, and one of the country's most famous exports. Another cash
crop - tourism - is fast on the rise, prompting the government
to segregate its top hotels, beaches and restaurants, banning
Cubans from enjoying their own resources.Mike Robertson
As soon as we pulled onto the autopista, however, there was
a roadblock and we were waved over. Lugo immediately pulled out
his documents for the officer. Another policeman, a big man, opened
the hatch and pulled away the foam pad. Gato laughed at being
caught - until the cop gave him a stern look.
The officer walked around the taxi, looking us over carefully
through the windows. When he returned to Lugo, he asked: "Are
these foreigners and Cubans?" Lugo said, "Yes."
"What country?" asked the officer.
"They are alpinistas," replied Lugo.
The officer hesitated, motioned Lugo to the front of the car and
asked in a low voice, "What country is Alpinista?"
"No, no - it is a sport," Lugo explained.
The edges of the officer's mouth slowly turned up into a small
smile. He handed Lugo back his documents, and, with a subtle flick
of his wrist, waved us through.
Armando Menocal is a human-rights and environmental activist,
a climbing guide, and founder of The Access Fund.
